UNDERSTANDING THE DIFFERENCE AND OVERLAP BETWEEN PLAGIARISM AND COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT

News and Views

UNDERSTANDING THE DIFFERENCE AND OVERLAP BETWEEN PLAGIARISM AND COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT

Tourism Minister, Lindiwe Sisulu has faced criticism after the publication on 7 January 2022 of her opinion piece entitled “Hi Mzansi, have we seen justice” in which she criticised the South African judiciary, amongst others.. She was accused of committing plagiarism as it was claimed that a large section of her opinion piece incorporated parts of a speech given by former United Kingdom attorney-general Dominic Grieve in 2013. Considering the traction this topic is receiving on social media, it is important to understand what exactly plagiarism entails and how plagiarism differs and, in some cases, overlaps with copyright infringement.

Plagiarism is the false representation/appropriation of words and thoughts of someone else without giving credit to the original author and ultimately passing them off as your own. Whereas copyright infringement is the unauthorised use or reproduction of copyright protected material without the permission of the rightful copyright holder and thereby infringing certain exclusive rights granted to the copyright holder. Plagiarism is a violation of intellectual creation but is not illegal (but is obviously considered a severe ethical violation) whereas copyright infringement is illegal in terms in the Copyright Act.

Both plagiarism and copyright infringement can happen at the same time or by the same act. It is however important that copyright can only subsist in works insofar as they are reduced to material form and cannot subsist in ideas that are not reduced to or expressed in some material form (this includes a performance of a work). The test for determining whether copyright infringement has taken place is a qualitative rather than a quantitative one. This means that even if a minimal but essential part of the work is copied it can still constitute copyright infringement.

Another aspect to consider is the territorial nature of intellectual property and the application of the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works (1886) -specifically how this convention provides contracting states with national treatment in the protection of works subject to copyright protection. The Berne Convention makes provision for the protection of works originating in one of the contracting countries and ultimately making it possible for copyright to subsist in any other country that is a contracting state. This means that if an original work was created in the United Kingdom, it will also have copyright protection in South Africa, as both these territories are members of the Berne Convention.

Understanding the differences between plagiarism and copyright infringement is paramount to the defences and remedies available to enforce rights against infringers.

Sonica Wilken

Associate
Attorney
Trade Mark Prosecution Department
Email: sonicaw@kisch-ip.com
Tel: +27 11 324 3133

This Post Has 23 Comments

  1. Office Chairs in Atlanta

    Revolutionize Your Workspace with Freedman’s Office Chairs in Atlanta

    **Embrace Productivity and Comfort: Freedman’s
    Office Chairs in Atlanta**

    In the bustling city of Atlanta, where innovation meets tradition, Freedman’s
    Office Furniture introduces its exclusive range of ergonomic office chairs.
    Located at 3379 Peachtree Rd NE, Atlanta, GA 30326, our showroom caters
    to the discerning tastes of residents in neighborhoods like Ansley Park and Baker Hills, offering
    premium office seating solutions that combine style and functionality.

    **Elevate Your Workspace in the Heart of Atlanta**

    Atlanta, founded in 1836, stands as a testament to a rich history and a thriving
    metropolis. With a population of 496,461 (2021) and 227,388 households,
    the city continues to evolve while preserving its unique charm.
    Freedman’s commitment to providing modern office chairs
    aligns seamlessly with Atlanta’s spirit of progress and
    dynamism.

    **Navigating the Urban Hub: Interstate 20**

    Much like the smooth flow of Interstate 20, Freedman’s ergonomic
    office chairs embody a perfect blend of form and function. This mirrors Atlanta’s commitment to
    providing a conducive environment for businesses to flourish
    and individuals to excel in their professional endeavors.

    **Investing in Style: A Wise Choice for Atlanta Professionals**

    In a city that values aesthetics and innovation,
    opting for Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs is a statement of sophistication. Our collection not only enhances the visual
    appeal of your workspace but also complements Atlanta’s commitment to creating a work environment that fosters creativity and
    success.

    **Discovering Atlanta’s Landmarks and the Comfort of Freedman’s
    Chairs**

    Embark on a journey through Atlanta’s iconic landmarks while experiencing the
    unmatched comfort of Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs.

    Here are five fascinating facts about some of Atlanta’s cherished destinations:

    – **Atlanta Botanical Garden:** A 30-acre botanical garden showcasing an incredible variety of plants and flowers.

    – **Centennial Olympic Park:** Built for the 1996 Summer Olympics, this park serves as
    a gathering spot for locals and visitors.
    – **Atlanta History Center:** An extensive history museum featuring exhibits, historic houses,
    and gardens.
    – **College Football Hall of Fame:** Celebrating the rich
    history of college football with interactive
    exhibits and memorabilia.
    – **The “”It’s a living”” Street Art:** A vibrant
    street art scene in the city, offering colorful and dynamic murals.

    **Why Choose Freedman’s Ergonomic Office Chairs in Atlanta**

    Opting for Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs in Atlanta is not
    just a choice; it’s a commitment to elevate your workspace.
    Our stylish and comfortable chairs ensure that your office reflects the vibrant and dynamic spirit of Atlanta, making it an ideal place
    for productivity, innovation, and success.

    “Transform Your Work Environment with Freedman’s Office
    Chairs in Orlando

    **Revitalize Your Workspace: Discover Freedman’s Office
    Chairs in Orlando**

    In the heart of Orlando, where magic and modernity coexist, Freedman’s Office Furniture proudly presents its exclusive range of office chairs.
    Conveniently located at 200 E Robinson St Suite 1120, Orlando, FL 32801, our
    showroom caters to the diverse needs of residents in neighborhoods like Audubon Park and Colonial Town Center, offering premium office seating solutions that
    prioritize both comfort and style.

    **Elevate Your Work Experience in Orlando’s Lively Atmosphere**

    Orlando, founded in 1875, has grown into a vibrant city with a population of 309,154 (2021) and 122,607 households.
    Freedman’s commitment to providing high-quality office chairs resonates with Orlando’s lively and energetic atmosphere, offering residents the perfect blend of comfort and functionality
    for their workspaces.

    **Navigating the City: The Significance of Interstate
    4**

    Much like the seamless flow of Interstate 4, Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs seamlessly
    blend style and functionality. This mirrors Orlando’s commitment to
    providing an environment where residents can seamlessly navigate between work
    and leisure, making our chairs an ideal choice for those who value efficiency and aesthetics.

    **Investing in Comfort: An Informed Choice for Orlando Professionals**

    In a city known for its diverse attractions and entertainment,
    investing in Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs is a conscious decision. Our chairs not only
    enhance the aesthetics of your workspace but also align with Orlando’s commitment to providing a comfortable
    and conducive work environment.

    **Explore Orlando’s Attractions and Relax in Freedman’s Chairs**

    Embark on a journey through Orlando’s enchanting attractions while enjoying the unparalleled comfort of Freedman’s ergonomic office
    chairs. Here are five interesting facts about some of Orlando’s most
    beloved landmarks:

    – **Walt Disney World Resort:** The most visited vacation resort globally,
    spanning over 25,000 acres.
    – **Universal Studios Florida:** An iconic film and television studio theme park, featuring thrilling
    rides and attractions.
    – **Lake Eola Park:** A scenic park in downtown Orlando with a picturesque
    lake and swan boats.
    – **Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts:** A state-of-the-art venue hosting various cultural
    and artistic performances.
    – **Orlando Museum of Art:** Showcasing a diverse collection of
    contemporary and classic art.

    **Why Choose Freedman’s Ergonomic Office Chairs in Orlando**

    Opting for Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs in Orlando is not just a decision; it’s a commitment to enhancing your workspace.
    Our stylish and comfortable chairs ensure that your office reflects the dynamic and creative spirit of Orlando, making it an ideal place for productivity,
    innovation, and success.

    “Discover Superior Comfort with Freedman’s Office
    Chairs in Atlanta

    **Elevate Your Workspace: Freedman’s Office Chairs in Atlanta**

    Nestled in the vibrant city of Atlanta, Freedman’s Office
    Furniture proudly introduces its exclusive collection of office
    chairs. Conveniently located at 3379 Peachtree Rd NE, Atlanta, GA 30326, our showroom caters to the
    diverse needs of residents in neighborhoods like Ansley Park and Buckhead, offering premium office seating solutions that blend comfort and sophistication seamlessly.

    **Crafting a Distinctive Workspace in Atlanta’s Dynamic Setting**

    Founded in 1836, Atlanta has evolved into a bustling city with a population of 496,461 (2021) and 227,
    388 households. Freedman’s commitment to delivering top-notch office chairs aligns perfectly
    with Atlanta’s dynamic and diverse setting, providing residents with ergonomic solutions that enhance both productivity and aesthetic appeal.

    **Navigating the Urban Hub: The Importance of Interstate 20**

    Much like the flow of Interstate 20, Freedman’s ergonomic office
    chairs effortlessly navigate the modern office landscape.
    This reflects Atlanta’s status as a vibrant urban hub, where residents
    value efficiency and style in equal measure, making our chairs the perfect choice
    for those seeking a superior seating experience.

    **Investing in Excellence: A Thoughtful Choice for Atlanta Professionals**

    In a city renowned for its rich history and cultural attractions, choosing Freedman’s ergonomic
    office chairs is a thoughtful investment. Our chairs not only elevate the visual appeal of
    your workspace but also resonate with Atlanta’s commitment
    to fostering innovation and success through a comfortable and ergonomic work environment.

    **Explore Atlanta’s Cultural Gems and Relax in Freedman’s Chairs**

    Immerse yourself in Atlanta’s cultural richness while enjoying the superior comfort of Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs.
    Here are five fascinating facts about some of Atlanta’s most iconic landmarks:

    – **Atlanta Botanical Garden:** A 30-acre garden showcasing an incredible variety of plants, flowers, and sculptures.

    – **Centennial Olympic Park:** Built for the 1996 Summer
    Olympics, it’s a gathering spot with fountains, events, and green spaces.

    – **Martin Luther King Jr. National Historic Site:
    ** Preserving the legacy of the civil rights leader, including his
    childhood home and Ebenezer Baptist Church.

    – **Piedmont Park:** A sprawling urban park with walking trails, sports
    facilities, and the picturesque Lake Clara Meer.

    – **The Fox Theatre:** A historic venue known for its Moorish architecture and
    hosting various performances.

    **Why Choose Freedman’s Ergonomic Office Chairs in Atlanta**

    Opting for Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs
    in Atlanta is not merely a decision—it’s a statement.

    Elevate your workspace with our stylish and comfortable chairs,
    embodying the spirit of innovation and success that defines
    Atlanta’s dynamic professional landscape.

    “Discover Unmatched Seating Comfort with Freedman’s Office Chairs
    in Orlando

    **Elevate Your Workspace: Freedman’s Office Chairs in Orlando**

    Located at 200 E Robinson St Suite 1120, Orlando, FL 32801, Freedman’s Office Furniture
    is proud to introduce its exclusive range of office chairs to the
    vibrant city of Orlando. Serving neighborhoods like Colonial Town Center and College Park, Freedman’s
    provides superior office seating solutions that prioritize both comfort
    and style.

    **Crafting a Distinctive Workspace in Orlando’s Sunshine State**

    Established in 1875, Orlando has transformed into a thriving city
    with a 2021 population of 309,154 and 122,607 households.
    Freedman’s dedication to delivering top-tier office chairs aligns
    seamlessly with Orlando’s sunny ambiance, offering residents ergonomic solutions that blend seamlessly with the
    city’s dynamic and energetic atmosphere.

    **Navigating the Urban Landscape: The Significance of Interstate 4**

    Much like the flow of Interstate 4, Freedman’s
    ergonomic office chairs effortlessly navigate the modern office landscape.
    This mirrors Orlando’s status as a hub of entertainment and
    technology, where residents seek innovative and comfortable
    seating solutions, making our chairs the ideal choice for those
    desiring a superior seating experience.

    **Investing in Excellence: A Thoughtful Choice for Orlando Professionals**

    In a city known for its theme parks and cultural attractions, choosing Freedman’s
    ergonomic office chairs is a thoughtful investment.
    Our chairs not only enhance the visual appeal of your workspace but also align with
    Orlando’s commitment to creating a vibrant and comfortable work environment that fosters creativity and success.

    **Explore Orlando’s Magical Attractions and Relax in Freedman’s Chairs**

    Immerse yourself in Orlando’s magical offerings while enjoying the unmatched comfort of Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs.

    Here are five fascinating facts about some of Orlando’s most
    iconic landmarks:

    – **Walt Disney World Resort:** The world’s most-visited vacation resort, featuring four theme parks and numerous attractions.

    – **Universal Studios Florida:** A film and television studio theme park with thrilling rides and shows.

    – **Lake Eola Park:** A downtown oasis with swan boats, live swans,
    and scenic walking paths.
    – **Orlando Science Center:** A hands-on science
    museum with interactive exhibits and engaging displays.

    – **Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts:** A modern venue
    hosting various live performances, including Broadway shows.

    **Why Choose Freedman’s Ergonomic Office Chairs in Orlando**

    Opting for Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs in Orlando is more than just
    a decision—it’s a commitment to excellence. Elevate your workspace with our stylish and comfortable chairs,
    embodying the spirit of innovation and success that defines
    Orlando’s dynamic professional landscape.

    “Revolutionize Your Workspace with Freedman’s Office Chairs in Atlanta

    **Experience Unparalleled Comfort: Freedman’s Office Chairs
    in Atlanta**

    Nestled at 3379 Peachtree Rd NE, Atlanta, GA 30326, Freedman’s Office Furniture proudly introduces its exceptional collection of
    office chairs to the dynamic city of Atlanta. Serving neighborhoods like Ansley Park and Buckhead, Freedman’s delivers office seating solutions
    that seamlessly combine ergonomic design with aesthetic appeal.

    **Redesigning Your Office Aesthetic: Freedman’s Office Chairs in Atlanta**

    Founded in 1836, Atlanta has evolved into a bustling metropolis with a 2021 population of 496,461 and 227,388 households.
    Freedman’s commitment to providing top-notch office chairs perfectly complements
    Atlanta’s modern and diverse atmosphere, offering residents seating solutions that embody both innovation and style.

    **Navigating the Cityscape: The Significance of Interstate 20**

    Much like the connectivity provided by Interstate 20,
    Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs seamlessly integrate
    into Atlanta’s diverse professional landscape.

    Reflecting Atlanta’s status as a cultural and economic hub, our chairs offer residents unparalleled comfort
    and style, making them the preferred choice for those seeking an exceptional seating
    experience.

    **A Commitment to Excellence: Choosing Freedman’s Chairs
    in Atlanta**

    In a city known for its rich history and cultural landmarks,
    choosing Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs is a statement of commitment to excellence.
    Our chairs not only enhance the visual appeal of your workspace but
    also align with Atlanta’s reputation for fostering innovation and success.

    **Explore Atlanta’s Rich Heritage and Relax in Freedman’s Chairs**

    Discover the vibrant history of Atlanta while enjoying the unrivaled comfort of Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs.

    Here are five intriguing facts about some of Atlanta’s iconic landmarks:

    – **Atlanta History Center:** A comprehensive history museum featuring exhibits on the Civil War and Southern history.

    – **Piedmont Park:** Atlanta’s premier green space, offering walking paths,
    sports facilities, and beautiful scenery.
    – **Martin Luther King Jr. National Historic Site:** Preserving the childhood home of
    the civil rights leader and featuring the Ebenezer Baptist Church.

    – **The Fox Theatre:** A historic performing arts
    venue known for its grand architecture and diverse entertainment.

    – **The High Museum of Art:** Atlanta’s leading art museum,
    showcasing a diverse collection of artwork.

    **Why Freedman’s Ergonomic Office Chairs Stand Out in Atlanta**

    Choosing Freedman’s ergonomic office chairs in Atlanta is a decision that transcends mere furniture.
    It’s a commitment to elevating your workspace with stylish and comfortable
    seating that resonates with Atlanta’s spirit
    of progress and achievement.

  2. Buying an Amazon account can offer numerous benefits.
    Firstly, users gain access to unlimited prime shipping services which ensures speedy and cost-effective deliveries.
    Additionally, an Amazon account allows for seamless purchase of a
    wide range of products, saving time and effort.

    Lastly, it opens up a plethora of offers, discounts, and
    exclusive deals. Buying an Amazon account is a worthwhile
    investment for those seeking convenience and savings.

  3. Syair Sdy

    I blog frequently and I really appreciate your content.
    Your article has really peaked my interest.
    I will take a note of your blog and keep checking for new information about once a week.
    I opted in for your RSS feed as well.

  4. ??????? ??????

    Wow! This blog looks just like my old one! It’s on a completely different subject but it has
    pretty much the same page layout and design. Great choice of colors!

  5. B-Sovety.ru

    Thank you for another wonderful article. Where else could anybody get that
    type of information in such a perfect method of writing?
    I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I am on the search
    for such info. https://b-Sovety.ru/user/SheritaShanks6/

  6. Keluaran HK

    Actually when someone doesn’t understand afterward its up to other viewers that they
    will help, so here it occurs.

  7. ???? ?????

    Pretty! This has been an extremely wonderful post.
    Thank you for providing this info.

  8. Hello there, I discovered your blog via Google even as searching
    for a similar subject, your website came up, it looks great.
    I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
    Hello there, simply changed into alert to your blog via Google, and found that it’s truly informative.
    I am gonna watch out for brussels. I’ll be grateful
    if you happen to proceed this in future.
    A lot of other folks will likely be benefited out of
    your writing. Cheers! http://Sl860.com/comment/html/?347296.html

  9. bigo99

    Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I really appreciate your efforts and I am waiting
    for your further post thank you once again.

  10. Heriberto

    I absolutely love your blog and find many of your post’s to
    be what precisely I’m looking for. Does one offer guest writers
    to write content to suit your needs? I wouldn’t mind producing a
    post or elaborating on a number of the subjects you write concerning here.

    Again, awesome web log! https://Bossgirlpower.com/forums/profile.php?id=64337

  11. c6068417836101369848

    You really make it seem so easy together with your presentation but I find this topic to be really something that I believe I would never understand.
    It seems too complex and extremely huge for me. I am having a
    look ahead in your subsequent submit, I’ll attempt to get the hang of it!

Leave a Reply